Critical Examination On Minztbergs ten Schools Of Thought Business Essay

Henry Mintzberg has classified strategic management into ten academic institutions of thought. The first three are the classical colleges of thought which adopt a typical view towards strategic management. These academic institutions insist that strategic management should consist of some standard rules and regulations. The rest of the seven schools will be the modern theories which consider proper management to be a mobile and powerful process. It should be applied by taking into account various parameters. This report will critically evaluate and evaluate the theories. It will seek to identify the strengths and restrictions of the procedure.


Henry Mintzberg has been a well known researcher that has written a number of books on proper management. The writer has classified tactical management into ten academic institutions of thought. The first three will be the classical classes of thought which take up a conventional view towards strategic management. These universities insist that tactical management should consist of some standard regulations. This helps to set-up high degrees of order and steadiness in the organizational environment.

The remaining seven schools will be the modern ideas which consider proper management to be always a mobile and dynamic process. It should be applied by firmly taking into account various variables. An organization must be strong and ground breaking as it responds to external threats and opportunities. In addition, the success of organizations is usually centered upon their capability to leverage their resources for most effective use. Strategic management is a proactive process where various variables have to be taken into account. A multifaceted strategy can help rectify various issues and obstructions.

It can lead to the success of different strategies which increase production and outcome. Mintzbergs classification has been thought to have advantages and restrictions. The classification helps professionals to employ a combo of different approaches for resolving business problems. A significant limitation is the fact that other schools are not brought up. This research newspaper will seek to investigate and evaluate the ten academic institutions of thought.

Classical University of Thoughts

Minztberg defines the classical institution of thoughts by focusing on traditional management rules and strategies.

The Design university believes that strategic management can be integrated through the presence of novel ideas and outlooks (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). The organization must formulate progressive and ingenious techniques in order to solve business problems. The external and internal factors are used as a means of dominating the market.

This approach leads to the creation of a stable and cohesive management framework. It creates a steady and frequent environment with the occurrence of active and proactive management. However the model is limited in the sense it adopts simple notions and presuppositions. It uses examined and proven approaches for resolving new problems which is often a risky enterprise (Johnson, Scholes, & Whittingon, 2008). The procedure of risk management is very flawed along the way due to many reasons. Tactical management is a powerful process that must consider various variables. This approach utilizes a linear and sequential procedure towards management problems. This process may become rigid and inflexible with the passage of time as new problems emerge.

The Planning institution uses standard operating types of procedures as a way of implementing strategic management in the task environment (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). It uses a step-by-step strategy where every variable is calculated in an effective and effective manner. This approach really helps to provide clear vision and mission declaration for the business.

Goals and goals can be decided in a predictable manner by the top management. It relies on facts as a means of attaining quality in the fluctuating business environment. Nevertheless the planning institution is hindered by its lack of ability to adopt a mobile and energetic procedure towards problems.

The procedure for strategic management may become reactionary since there could be no procedures to react to unforeseeable circumstances. It places an over reliance on goals and aims because it does not consider proper management that can be played a crucial role in the development of knowledge for the business enterprise organization.

The third traditional university is the positioning approach in which professionals conduct recurrent assessments of the encompassing environment. Industry trends, market position, product demand, and consumer needs are documented in a logical and useful manner (Probst & Raub, 1999). General market trends can be utilized as an instrument to enhance the strategic edge of business organizations.

The positioning school is hindered by its incapability to take into consideration political, social, and cultural capabilities. This can be damaging for the success of organizations in a multifaceted business environment. The institution focuses on large corporations that have the ability to conduct effective market research in the environment.

Modern Colleges of Thought

Strategic management in the modern time has been split into seven categories corresponding to research workers.

The Entrepreneurial college stresses the importance of charismatic management in formulating business procedures and procedures (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002).

Management can effectively put into action strategic processes by way of a combination of belief, point of view, understanding, and recognition.

Charismatic management helps the organization to resist problems available environment. This process is successful if the organization is facing critical emergencies. Nevertheless the school of thought is limited in the sense it can result in unforeseeable hazards and obstacles.

Charismatic leadership might adopt competitive regulations that are risky for the entire business venture. They are really successful during uncertain financial conditions where there is little or no regulation. This approach might not be successful in an environment with a couple of predefined regulations.

The Cognitive university applies strategic management by using psychological and mental strategies. It studies consumer habits in an productive and effective manner (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). It makes an attempt to investigate the rivals manners and activities.

Managers can apply mental models as a means of boosting existing business strategies. New opportunities or dangers can be recognized in a logical and sensible manner. A sound strategy can be carried out based upon previous times experiences of professionals. The institution of thought is hindered in its capability to implement useful approaches towards proper management.

The entire process is unable to develop impressive and critical ideas that are had a need to change the fortunes of business organizations working in a cut-throat environment. Public constructs are being used as a means formulating strategic management. However this is only relevant in theoretical point of view since it ignores other parameters present in the business enterprise environment. It targets laws and ideas rather than use a methodical methodology for tactical management. Such a methodology uses empirical data and observation as a means of resolving problems. It also vigorously studies hypotheses in an successful and effective manner.

The Learning school argues that strategic management is developed through knowledge acquisition by the business enterprise organization. An experienced firm has generated a tank of knowledge and competence (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). These resources enable it to perform a tactical management procedure in a proficient and experienced manner. The lessons learned from past experiences can be used to combat new hazards and obstacles available environment.

The approach is insufficient to battle the threats faced during emergencies. It might lead to misunderstanding in the long term due to the absence of clear and crystal goals.

The Power institution believes that strategic management can be accomplished through the practice of concession and compromise. The essential stakeholders need to be unified by creating common floor that is effective for the business corporation (David, 2006).

The balance of electric power between various interest teams should be preserved in order to guarantee the success of proper management. This process is limited by its give attention to politics that can be a chaotic and challenging process. It could give attention to trivial issues through the procedure of negations and bargain. The organization might fail to reconcile the various hobbies of the stakeholders.

The Cultural University is based after the idea that proper management should be employed in a shared and put together manner. Every office in the organization must coordinate business activities to achieve long-term and short term goals (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). A consensus should be developed by taking the counsel and advice of various groups.

The overall consensus should be utilized for creating a powerful and effective technique for the business organization (David, 2006). This theory has helped organizations in using social ideals and norms to make smart decisions. Such attitudes and norms help the business to make effective consumption of limited resources. The business can coordinate and incorporate its activities by using different methodologies and tools. The dominating values in the organization are advertised by using a methodical and logical approach. Nevertheless the theory is limited in the sense which it can ignite opposition to change in the organizational environment.

The prominent group might misuse its capabilities and privileges to be able to maintain its clout and authority. The ethnic theory can be used to legitimize existing ideals, norms, and behaviour. It can use the consensus of almost all as an excuse to withstand change. Additionally, it may lead to ambiguities in the complete process which might lead to problems and hurdles.

The Environmental institution believes that strategic management should be reactionary in characteristics (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). This means that management should react only when they can be faced with road blocks in the external environment. The constraints enforced by the surroundings can become a catalyst for change.

The exterior environment is the major indicator of strategy for organizations. This means that other variables have to be sidelined in order to formulate an effective and effective strategy. A significant limitation of the idea is the fact it cannot take up realistic and exact approaches towards proper management. That is due to the fact so it ignores or sidelines the inner variables that can boost the overall performance of business organizations.

Finally it can be an anathema of proactive management that anticipates changes in the exterior environment. It does not allow the application of contingency ideas which can be used to attain excellence in the business environment.

The Configuration institution feels that organizations must rejuvenate and restructure their basic constructions in order to achieve success available environment (Mintzberg & Ahlstrand, 2002). The transformation of organizations should arise by using a slow and progressive approach.

The organization will need mechanisms which is often used as the catalyst for change and invention (Moore, 2003). In addition, there is the need for ground breaking and creative techniques which is often used for attaining superiority in the cutthroat environment. This theory allows organizations to tolerate cycles of instability that can wreck havoc in the surroundings. It could use a good and ground breaking strategy which is situated upon floor realities.

However the theory is limited in the sense that some organizational structures is probably not appropriate. The definition of restructuring and rejuvenation is based upon the notion of managers.


Managers can apply mental models as a means of enhancing existing business strategies. New opportunities or threats can be diagnosed in a rational and practical manner. A audio strategy can be integrated based upon earlier times experiences of managers. The school of thought is hindered in its potential to implement practical approaches towards proper management. Proper management is a dynamic process that needs to consider various variables. This approach utilizes a linear and sequential methodology towards management problems. This technique may become rigid and inflexible with the duration of time as new problems emerge.

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)