Management Of Turmoil And Dispute Resolution

The aspect of the construction industry in Hong Kong is in a way that there is an existing conflict between your major construction task participants, owners, design pros and contractors. The development industry is well-known for high degrees of issues and disputes.

Construction is construction, and no subject how complicated the technology. Additionally it is a project-based industry with each project being unique. Inside a project life circuit, a large range of separate firm are participating. Failures by one party can affect those engaged in a task and, as work often takes substantial periods during which national financial circumstances can transform, it is unavoidable that dispute will arise.

From the above-mentioned circumstance, it should not be surprised that the techniques of turmoil management and dispute image resolution in development industry tend to be developed, compared to the industry, one might be willing to ask the questions as to whether there may be any expect the industry in attempting to reduce the serious and extent of conflicts and disputes? According to Fenn et al(1997), turmoil can be supervised, possibly to point of protecting against it from resulting in dispute whereas, dispute require resolution and, therefore, are associated with different justifiable issue.

The purpose of this newspaper will firstly explain the definition of turmoil management and dispute quality. And also identify the causes of the conflicts and disputes in Hong Kong construction industry. Finally, this review will also identify the way of formal conflict management and the dispute image resolution methods to be utilized.

2. Conflict Management in Structure Industry:

2. 1-The classification of conflict management

Conflict may be defined as a competition between people who have opposing needs, ideas, values, worth or goal. Discord on team is unavoidable; however, the results of turmoil are not predetermined. Turmoil might increase and lead to non-productive results or turmoil can be beneficially resolved and business lead to quality final products.

Therefore, learning to manage conflict is vital to a high-performance team. Though very few people go looking for conflict, more often than not. Issue results because of lacking communication between people who have regard to their needs, ideas, values, goals, or beliefs. Conflict management is the theory that all issues cannot consequentially be solved, but learning how to control conflicts can decrease the odds of non-productive escalation.

According to Algert, N. E. , and Watson, K. (2002), Conflict management includes obtaining skills related to conflict quality, self-awareness about discord modes, turmoil communication skills, and building a structure for management of issue in your environment.

2. 2-The factors behind conflict in engineering

Construction is significantly not the same as manufacturing, in which the same goods are produced one thousand times. Also, construction does not allow for the change of variable while holding the others fixed to be able to review its effects. The nature of the construction referred to earlier so conflicts among owners, design specialists and contractors are standard.

To claim that these parties are inclined to confrontational connections and conflict will be a major declaration in the engineering industry.

Owners are even arguing with the design professionals over design service describe of mistakes and overlook in design services rendered, cosmetic factors and budget overruns.

(p. 4-white)

Accordingly, Howell et. al (1998, cited by Vorster 1993) proposed a nomenclature of elements that summarize four triggers behind discord in the development environment
Incomplete scope classification

The design professional's responsibility to specify and design the task scope in order to meet up with the owner's useful, budgetary, time and environmental project criteria. When the look professional does not meet their responsibility, the dog owner is nearly always dissatisfied with the effect, with the result that rigorous correspondence soon ensues between the parties. Also, when the range of the task is unclear, this reveals an unhappy relationship for future between your owner and the contractor, arguing about the scope and quality of the task, and whether in truth the task is properly identified by the contract documents made by the look professional.

Inappropriate contract type

Contracts are endemic as causes of discord within the construction industry; almost every level of the building process is regulated by an arrangement of some kind. Some of the areas of contract dispute are breach of deal in agreement clause interpretation, inspection of work clauses, indemnity clauses, repayment of products, and liability to third people, just to name a few possible regions of agreement dispute.

Poor communication

Infrastructures are unique products with more complex production process than other and most of building products are a combined effort of several individuals or organization. Numerous experts have contribution to execute a building in various capacities. Among development associates, each may have different target with regards to their profession, but their primary goal ought to be to complete the project within a given plan. Discord between associates may arise when their goals are inconsistent. Also, their interpretations of deal documents, conditions, and conditions can diverge, resulting in discrepancies and conflict. In a nutshell, all factors behind conflict within an area are interrelated.


For exterior: a) Environmental concerns; b) Public impacts; c) Economics;

d) Political dangers; e) Weather; f) Legislation;

g) Unforeseen site condition.

For inner: a) Problem in design; b) Structure methods and workmanship

In amount 10. 3 which is one of these of what the dog owner should consider when discovering potential conflicts. We are able to identify which ones may be realized at the interfaces among the multiple participants in an agency construction management delivery system. Certain issues in the relationship among the dog owner, developer, CM and trade builder can be taken away in various situations if a different delivery system is decided on.

(P. 205-White)

2. 3-Methods of conflict management found in engineering industry in HK

In the engineering industry, ask anyone if they completed a construction project without the conflict. The answer 100% of that time period will be "NO". The successful task managers must be implement ways of avoid or keep an eye on discord in their engineering project.

The pursuing common steps are used by the task managers when developing a successful issue management

Conflict recognition;

Conflict research;

Design and implementation of a conflict management;

Monitoring and overview of the issue management.

(P. 202-White)

Prevention is the best method in the management of the issue in structure industry. The techniques include

Dispute review planks or advisors;


Quality (Total quality management and quality assurance);

Procurement systems

which are non-blinding process.

Baden-Hellard (1988) emphasized that building industry has an integral potential for discord arising from the differences always present in values, ideas and interest. Thus, when distinctions arises from unforeseen events, no matter how well the clients, design team and companies have handled the project, better ways of resolving the variations are needed.

Dispute review boards or advisors:

It is almost impossible to complete a big construction project with no any disputes develop between your people. The DRB is a -panel of two neutral people who are picked by the people to the development agreement, usually the task owner and the general contractor. The project owner will stipulate in the features for bidding the task.

DBR supply the techniques and mechanisms never to only help settle disputes but also can offer a strategy to prevent the potential discord from ever going on. The potential discord to the DRB means that plausible argument at each engineering stages and the grade of the display of cases.

The first assembly of the DRB usually takes place well before the commencement of the construction project and will continue to meet until the DRB users are well-known all of the aspects of the project. After the project begins, each DRB will most likely meet on a regularly scheduled basic such as once each month or once each quarter, etc. Besides, site visit can ne made with respect to the requirements of the project.


Negotiation must be undertaking to solve the discord before it come to a more serious stage and change into dispute. The get-togethers must get together and tackle an agreeable settlement through communication.

The pursuing two example shown a simple negotiation between the primary contractor(MC) and a subcontractor(SC) who is unable to meet the purpose in the deal.

Example A

SC: I'll not be able to finish this technique on time.

MC: You need to be finish theses according the time agenda.

SC: I want three extra weeks to complete it.

MC:You cannot have extra three weeks.

SC: If I do not get three weeks, i can not complete this technique promptly.

MC:No, you will complete as scheduled, if you really cannot finish off it, we will collect harm and replace you.

The example A is a position-based kind of negotiation that will go around in circle until one of gatherings abandons its position. It is not clear why the gatherings are even arguing.

Example B

SUB: I will not have the ability to finish this technique promptly.

MC: What are the reasons and why is it possible to not finish off as planned?

SUB: My distributor will not in a position to deliver the materials until next week so I need three extra weeks to finish it.

MC: You have to know the timetable is very restricted for this task. Any kind of other suppliers that can deliver on time?

SUB: Yes, however the suppliers are more costly than the injuries given by finishing late.

MC: Although you are responsible for reaching the concentrate on, I also understand your predicament. Actually, I understand some other suppliers that might be able to solve these problems and I will contact them as soon as possible.

The example B is an interest-based kind of negotiation that can be come to a mutually agreeable solution even the source of the conflict is uncovered.

According to these two examples, a successful negotiation should lead to a solution suitable to both people that won't damage their romance and implies cooperation, trust and common objectives.

Quality (Total quality management (TQM) or confidence):

According to Gardiner et al (1992), the most confliction stages are discovered within the business, closely accompanied by the problem of quality and control. Probably one of the most confliction levels is the quality issue so a good and ideal quality management or control system should be given. It can decrease the frequency of turmoil.

TQM can be an considerable management system which

Focuses on getting together with owners' needs by giving quality services at a price that provides value to the owners;

Is compel by the search for continuous improvement in every operations;

Understand everyone in the organization;

Observe an organization as an internal system with a objective rather than as specific parties acting to increase their own shows;

Emphasize teamwork and a high level of workers.

Procurement systems:

The procurement system is one of all effective methods in reduction of conflict so that it should be found in the earlier stage of the task life circuit.

According to Bennett et al (1990), the procurement system developed the roles and associations, which constitute the business. It establishes the entire management composition and systems, which helps to form the entire values and varieties of the project.

The Procurement System for Building provides support for

Selection of appropriate procurement and contracting strategies, and nomination of a proper Principal in the contracts;

Preparation of tender documents and agreements predicated on standard varieties;

Selection of contractors and consultants with proven performance files;

Effective management of contracts, including clause commentaries, sample words and checklists;

Maintenance of a powerful performance management system through monitoring and reporting; and

Resolution of contractual promises and disputes.

(NSW Authorities (2000), Procurement system for engineering. Available from

NSW Administration, NSW Federal government Procurement

Web site: http://www. nswprocurement. com. au/Procurement-System-for-Construction. aspx [Accessed: March 13, 2011]. )

3. Dispute Image resolution in Structure Industry:

3. 1-The description of Dispute Resolution

Dispute resolution is about identifying the root causes of issue and stopping and managing discord with the goal of resolving disputes or conflict during the building process to avoid post-construction cases, litigation, and related costs.

According to Whitfield(1994), resolve disputation can use either informal resolution methods such as negotiation and choice dispute resolution(ADR) or formal quality methods such as litigation and arbitration.

3. 2-The causes of dispute in engineering

Disputes tend to be the outcome of unwell considered procurement routines, insufficient preparatory planning and design activity, or poor project and commercial management techniques.

If the conflict happened in engineering site, all functions are decided to each other. There is absolutely no further issue because targets of both get together become same. But if one or both get together becomes intransigent, then the conflict may turn to a dispute. In other expression, disputes are come up when parties are unable to manage their conflicts properly. Dispute can be explained as a disagreement between people in connection with their objectives.

Construction failure may create dispute between the parties in building sites. According to Feld and carper; Kaminetzky (1997), failure during the engineering phase can include

1) Overloading.

2) Improper temporary supports.

3) Inadequate planning and execution of engineering process.

4) Insufficient inspection.

5) Insufficient safeness factors.

6) Inadequate training of construction industry workers.

Feld, J. and Carper, K. (1997). Construction

Failure. John Wiley &

Sons, NY.

Cause of customer:

1) Inability to reply in well-timed manner.

2) Inadequate tracing mechanisms for RFI (Request for information).

3) Reluctant to check on for constructability, clearness and completeness.

4) Discrepancies / ambiguities in deal documents.

5) Poor communications between and among the parties involved in theproject.

6) Failing to appoint an overall project manager.

7) Lowest price mentality in engagement of companies and designers.

The absence of "team spirit" among the list of participants.

8) Deficient management, guidance and coordination work on the

part of the job.

Cause of custom:

1) Failure to understand its obligations under design team deal.

2) Over-design and underestimate the costs involve.

3) Inadequate in wide open and factual communication.

4) Past due information given and cumbersome approaches to RFIs

5) Design and specification oversights and problems or omissions resulting

from uncoordinated civil, structural, architectural, mechanised and

electrical designs.

6) Incompleteness of pulling and specs.

Cause of service provider:

1) Inadequate service provider management, guidance and coordination.

2) Lack of understanding and agreement in agreement procurement.

3) Failure to understand and correctly bid or price the works.

4) Reluctance to get clarification.

5) Failing to plan and implement the changes of works.

6) Inadequate CPM Scheduling and revise requirements.

7) Delay/ suspension system of works.

Fenn et al (1997) provides a synopsis of the conclusions of nine frequently cited

studies of the sources of disputes
3. 3-Methods of dispute resolution used in engineering industry in HK

According to Carmichael (2002), the step method of dispute resolution as below.

An attempt is made to handle the dispute at the particular level of which it occurs, in an acceptable time;

If this fails, involve parties at an increased level with decision making power, and the potential to stay in the passions of any commercial solution;

If this fails, check out an ADR methodology using and 3rd party alternative party;

If this fails, arbitration or litigation will be utilized.

3. 3. 1 Informal resolution methods
a) Negotiation

Negotiation is a common dispute image resolution method, which most of us are using in every day. There is absolutely no neutral third party for the negotiation, only the disputants. Additionally it is defined as a means to reach mutual contract through communication, corresponding to Down, L. J. (2009), (p. 140-white)

Negotiation is known as by most appropriate way to resolve any dispute in construction industry. It had been because negotiation is not expensive and can be maintained romance with the related celebrations.

However, there are also negative sides of negotiation. For instance, if the related get-togethers negotiated an extended and protected period of conversation, the negotiation will be fail because they're not blinding. Besides, it can be an informal resolution method, it can allow any surprise issue or irrelevant factors rising.

b) Substitute Dispute Resolution (ADR)

ADR is a collective term used to spell it out ways of resolving disputes that are alternatives to litigation and arbitration and which usually offer a less expensive solution.

For example

Mediation: It has appeared as an extremely used form of dispute resolution, involving a neutral third party working to facilitate effective discussions to enable a mutually appropriate settlement.

In mediation, the functions explore options, measuring the talents and weaknesses of these respective situations.

Mediation can save significant amounts of time and cost in resolving a dispute and can also help the celebrations to re-establish trust and prevent damage to ongoing human relationships.

Adjudication: That is a quick and relatively inexpensive way of resolving a dispute. The adjudicator's decision is normally upheld by the courts therefore it is important to ensure that all the relevant facts are put in leading of the adjudicator.

Adjudication will not necessarily achieve final settlement of an dispute because either of the get-togethers has the to have the same dispute heard afresh in court docket.

However, experience demonstrates nearly all adjudication decisions are accepted by the gatherings as the ultimate result.

(Powell, J. David. 2005. Boundary Dispute Resolution in Great britain & Wales Surveyors and Solicitors Working Together to Resolve Problems. Proceedings of Cairo: Egypt. )

(Add chep lak kok adr stand, make reference to white publication)

Because of the next potential advantages, it will probably be worth considering using ADR early on in a lawsuit or even before you files a lawsuit.

Advantage of ADR

Better communication;

Continued method of trading;

More options for settlement deal;

Reduced costs in achieving settlement;


Control of end result and the process.

3. 3. 2 Formal resolution methods

a) Litigation

On occasions, alternative dispute resolution methods are not successful in resolving disputes, resulting with the gatherings resorting to formal litigation through the courts.

According to Whitfield(1994), the process of litigation is from the issue of an writ to a ability to hear and then to a judgment. Among the failures of the legal process has been the rate with which solicitors have been prepared to concern writ. After writ has been issue, the plaintiff cannot simply withdraw his writ and forget the subject. If he have so, the counterclaim would be found against him along with the cost.

The related development companies need to provide litigation support services for both formal litigation and substitute dispute resolution as follows

Programme delay evaluation;

Forensic research;

Preparation of claims of case and claims of defence;

Paralegal support.

b) Arbitration

According to Ashworth (2005), Arbitration is a legal technique for the image resolution of dispute outside the courts. The get-togethers refer the dispute to a neutral, educated person (arbitrator or arbitral tribunal) who then gives the ultimate decision (award) to which both the parties agree with the fact.

Arbitration, instead of court proceedings, as the last resort to resolving disputes in development agreements has been commonly found in Hong Kong as well as internationally.

Although intended to be a less formal plus more flexible alternative to litigation, arbitration can be as thorough and time-consuming as litigation, especially for engineering disputes.

The related companies should be employ the know-how in representing them in arbitration proceedings and managing the whole arbitration process from the appointment of arbitrators, drafting of pleadings, interacting with interlocutory proceedings to the hearing stage and beyond.

Where necessary, legal representatives who experienced in building disputes to supply the most complete services to the business in arbitration.

4. Realization:

Each construction tasks are unique and complex undertakings. A distinctive group of drawings and features are used to describe each construction phases. The drawings and related documents generally performed by a general contractor and several subcontractors, many of whom never have work together recently. The unique aspects of each task and the unique constitution of every construction team are normal reasons for disagreements to occur.

Disputes can be generated in virtually any environment; indeed, turmoil may appear whenever two individuals make an effort to work together. These disputes often matter topics such as changes, differing site conditions, delays, and obligations.

Many researchers got attempted to determine the sources of discord and disputes within the development industry.

Besides, H. Murray Hohns (1979) contributes to the conclusion that the precise factors behind the discord and dispute can be mainly traced to the following five options

1) Errors, defects or omissions in contract documents;

2) Underestimation of the cost - by the client, the builder, or both;

3) Changes in conditions, (e. g. unexpected surface conditions);

4) Promises from end-users (rights of owners and tenants);

5) People mixed up in structure process.

When confliction is occur in the development industry, the importance of proper turmoil recovery method and conformity with formal methods can't be over-stressed. If disputes proceedings become inevitable, it ought to be some comfort to know that proper choice dispute resolution is a favorable condition rather than drawback.

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)