CRIMINOLGICAL OVERVIEW OF 'MURDER ON THE SUNDAY MORNING'

'Murder on the Sunday day' is a documentary film predicated on a genuine life event that occurred in Jacksonville, Florida in the May of 2000. This 111-minute movie was aimed by the French documentary filmmaker Jean-Xavier de Lestrade and was actually released under the name Uncoupable ideal. It received the Oscar prize for the best documentary in 2002.

The film brilliantly depicts an ignominious false conviction of any innocent 15-12 months old for a criminal offenses he never dedicated, the cover-up of the real culprits behind the offense, and finally the clemency of any public defender coming to his rescue in the courtroom.

The plot comes from the incident of Mary Ann Stephens, a 65-yr old visitor from Georgia being taken dead by the black assailant. The police arrested the first 'convenient dark culprit' available, a dark-colored African American teen, Brendon Butler, who was simply on his way to employment interview. The teen was subsequently denied the right to make his phone call or contact an attorney, interrogated mercilessly for an unreasonable timeframe, threatened, racially abused, tortured in physical form and psychologically, and compelled to sign a phony confession admitting to presenting committed the criminal offense. The inactive woman's partner, though having trapped a view of the real culprit through the shootout, was compelled by the authorities to publicly identify and proclaim Butler as the assailant. The purpose behind the forceful arrest and the subsequent psychological torture of the innocent Butler was simply the preservation of the holiday trade in the state of hawaii.

A open public defender, Pat McGuinness, however, takes up the truth and defends Brendon Butler in a case that is extraordinarily riveting. The courtroom views enacted by McGuinness could probably be counted among the most notable classics of the genre. The well-written trial speaks volumes about the perils of 'instant justice' meted out or more aptly, 'justice of convenience' that is really as common as real justice nowadays.

A criminological evaluation on why Brendon Butler was framed should take into account the facts that his residence was nearly a mile from the place of the event; he was an African-American, a member of an cultural group historically infamous to be convicted in racial offences and his locality being a lower-class urban one, with high offense rates. The victim's partner, a white man in a state of trauma, might also have been under great pressure to identify the sufferer with unclear images of a black man shooting his better half.

The next question to be responded is approximately the instantaneous arrest and conviction of Brendon. Could they not need made a broader search? The answers may be obtained when one considers the fact that in Florida, travel and leisure is a major industry. Individuals who earn their livelihood out of this industry would definitely not want Florida to be known as a risky spot to visit. The image of a family focused place was to be associated with Florida at any cost. The police could have been under great pressure to dispose off the case as fast as possible to create a graphic of a strong and efficient supervision. Also the fact that the victim was a traveler and the news headlines of the murder being reported by the press might have put the police under a whole lot of pressure to create a suspect who would at least around match the explanations available at that time.

Another question to be replied is the gruesome way in which the teenager was tortured. Maybe it's guessed that the officers tend to be puppets in the hands with their superiors. They are put under great pressure to clear as much cases as fast as possible. As per regulations, when an arrest is manufactured, the case will be considered cleared notwithstanding the reality behind the criminal offense. As far as they were worried, the killer was captured. However, this discussion does not show the meticulousness of the police.

We may also take a look at why the whole bunch of the police team was so unequivocal in placing the blame on Brendon and torturing him to the extreme. The incident details show that the key third degree interrogator was the child of the sheriff of the region. Hence, he could have had the unofficial power to take decisions on the kind of interrogation and on viewing this; others would have sensed that they are only respecting their superior's specialist in joining hands to torture him.

The only saving grace is McGuinness, who played a significant part in cases like this by defending Butler. Butler was fortunate enough to acquire such a savior in his time of extreme stress. Not absolutely all defenders are so gutsy or articulate. It had been only because of McGuiness skills and devotion that Brendon Butler was became innocent. Usually, it is seen that in such instances, the conviction of your innocent is used by the machine to keep their pride.

Though there are hues of the racial kind of movie of famous brands 'Cry Liberty', when one recognizes that the key interrogator who was simply instrumental in making Butler confess a offense he never does is himself a dark man, the similarity ends there. The basic & most convincing underlying meaning is that of a deep and ingrained insincerity in america administration in things of justice and a business-like attitude on the commercial improvement of the united states making them stick it above the rest.

Obviously, there are very a great deal of unanswered questions in this event. A more sensitive and unbiased approach to such incidents would be the first step towards molding a properly upright culture.

References

Dooley, B. and Delisi, M. , 2007-11-14 "Racial Profiling: Rhetoric Or Fact?" Paper shown at the annual appointment of the AMERICAN Culture OF CRIMINOLOGY, Atlanta Marriott Marquis, Atlanta, Georgia Online . 2009-05-23 from http://www. allacademic. com/meta/p201257_index. html

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)