Ethics in Psychology and Felony Justice

Ethical behavior is important within any self-control whether automobile mechanics or brain cosmetic surgeons. Two disciplines in which ethical behavior is especially important are the disciplines of legal justice and mindset due to the vulnerable express of the individuals which are encountered on a daily basis. Straying from conformity of ethical rules in either of the disciplines could result in mental destruction in psychology, fake arrests or acquittals in legal justice, or termination and dishonor within either self-control. This manuscript talks about a couple honest dilemmas within the disciplines of psychology and unlawful justice as well as provides examples of each. The manuscript also briefly talks about the similar parameters which make each discipline delicate to ethical action.

Ethical Dilemmas in Psychology and Felony Justice

Within any profession, whether it's a psychology, police, information casting, or even a car mechanic, a person's integrity performs a pivotal role in how successful their efforts turn out. Integrity, as defined by the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, is "organization adherence to a code of especially moral or imaginative worth" (Integrity, 2010). One whose integrity is compromised may be regarded as irresponsible, dishonest, and possibly even immoral. A very important factor that impacts one's integrity is set up individual conducts themselves in an ethical manner. Ethics within in a profession are a set of moral principals used to ascertain whether a certain tendencies is right or wrong. Most disciplines have an ethical code whether it's implied or actually noted. For example, the American Psychological Relationship has a set of ethical principals shared by which psychologists may evaluate whether a specific habit or action is ethically acoustics (American Psychological Relationship, 1992). Alternatively, car mechanics have no generally accepted, posted, ethics code. In the case like this, organizations may be authorized by different organizations that have developed an ethical code or they may develop one of their own (Technicians R Us, 2010). This manuscript will discuss some moral dilemmas which have been encountered and researched within the fields of psychology and criminal justice.

Literature Review

The American Psychological Association posted a couple of guidelines and rules which govern honest actions within the mental health field (American Psychological Connection, 1992). These rules cover most if not all aspects of mindset from therapy to research. It is after this base that the options of ethical dilemmas within the field of mindset are founded. Also based after these ethical suggestions Sherwin (1998) made a assertion regarding the effects of unethical behavior after the vulnerable individuals that psychological professionals come across on a regular basis.

Peternelj-Taylor (2002) and Lambie (2005) both provided types of ethical dilemmas professionals within the mental health field may face. Peternelj-Taylor creates on the issue of over- and under-involvement with patients. Wartenburg (1990) talks about the way the ideal amount of involvement for a specialist within the subconscious field to obtain with a customer lies in a location called transformative ability. Everett and Gallop (2001) continued to describe the perfect purpose of transformative power.

Lambie's (2005) structure involved the divulgence of suspected child maltreatment by school counselors. Crenshaw, Lichtenberg, and Bartell (1993) as well as Sechrist (2000) performed analyses that found problems in the amount of times that suspected child maltreatment is reported. Wilson, Ireton, & Timber (1997) mentioned how this dilemma ranks high among the list of concerns of supporting professionals. Your choice to article suspected child abuse is governed not only ethically but lawfully as well. In 1974, the National Child Abuse Protection and Treatment Work (PL 93-247) provided a classification of child misuse (42 USCS 5101). Most state governments have also enacted statutes and lawful restrictions which make divulgence of suspected child maltreatment required by law North Carolina General Statutes (2003).

The differing occupations within the field of unlawful justice are also governed by units of ethical rules. One ethical problem which is experienced within law enforcement is the use of excessive pressure. The situation of Rodney Ruler has an excellent, high-profile example upon which to starting the effects of this problem (Cannon, 1997). Schoch & Lin (2007) found that, even several years following the event, a degree of civil unrest as well as a deep sitting mistrust of the legal justice community still is present.

Vidmar (2002) talks about the ethical issue of launching prejudice within the courtroom. He uses examples of cases in which he was called to investigate the quantity of prejudice including Regents of the University of California vs. Genentech (1999) and R. v. Reynolds (1997). In such cases he found that it generally does not take much for prejudice to find its way into the courtroom setting up and influence the opinions of these involved.


Ethical Dilemmas in Psychology

As one may easily ascertain, moral behavior in virtually any aspect of mindset is extremely important. In most cases, those that take part in subconscious research or receive a treatment of some kind from a psychologist are in a prone state of mind. Sherwin (1998) said it best saying "without a strong principle of respect for patient autonomy, patients are vulnerable to abuse or exploitation, when their fragile and dependant position makes them easy targets to provide the pursuits (e. g. financial, educational, or social impact) of others" (p. 20). In instances like this, the psychologist must be amazingly careful with the actions they take or risk causing harm that may take years to take care of or may even be irreversible. Effects from the psychologist may include having their requirements questioned or perhaps even legal activities. The ethical recommendations for the willpower of mindset are printed in the Honest Principals of Psychologists and Code of Conduct (American Psychological Connection, 1992). With this section the manuscript will cover some honest dilemmas which have been discussed within posted literature.

One ethical problem that psychologists may encounter involves connections with patients outside of the patient-therapist or patient-researcher romantic relationship. Peternelj-Taylor (2002), a nurse who worked well as a team leader on a intimate offender unit of your maximum security forensic clinic, discussed this problem at length. Inside the manuscript, the researcher discusses psychologists' over-involvement and under-involvement with a patient. Over-involvement with an individual includes romantic relationships past patient-therapist relationships including friendships or erotic relations with patients. Under-involvement includes tendencies which borderlines disregarding the patient which includes avoidance of patients or not discovering or responding to patient problems with sufficient detail. As you may imagine, each one of these circumstances may be bad for not only the patient but also the therapeutic integrity of the psychologist.

During patient-therapist connections, it should be the purpose of the psychologist to remain in an area between the two extremes of over-involved and under-involved power assertion. Wartenburg (1990) refers to this area as transformative ability which focuses after a sort of partnership with the individual. In patient-therapist relationships that maintain a transformative vitality relation, the emphasis is positioned upon dealing with the patient in resolving their problems rather than overtop or regardless of. Everett and Gallop (2001) stated that "the purpose of transformative power is mutual liberation - from dependency (for your client) and from being depended on (for the professional)" (p. 124). Essentially, this expresses what should be the ultimate goal of the patient-therapist romance.

Another ethical problem experienced within the emotional occupation is divulging information about suspected child maltreatment or overlook that was obtained during remedy. Lambie (2005) made up a manuscript speaking about how this dilemma affects professional university counselors. One would presume that, with legal statutes necessitating divulgence, the decision to report instances of suspected mistreatment would immediately be reported when it is experienced though this is not always the situation. In an evaluation by Crenshaw, Lichtenberg, and Bartell (1993) the experts found that, in many instances, helping experts choose against reporting suspected abuse. Also, a report by the National National Child Maltreatment and Neglect Occurrence Study discovered that school personnel only reports a small ratio of suspected maltreatment situations to Child Protective Services (Sechrist, 2000). Research has found that encountering a suspected case of child maltreatment is high among the fears of aiding professionals (Wilson, Ireton, & Lumber, 1997). It's been said that, while professionals know about their legal obligation to article such circumstances, procedural uncertainty about how exactly to start reporting among other things are deterrents (Lambie, 2005).

The decision of assisting professionals to article suspected abuse is governed by both legal and honest guidelines. Lambie (2005) discusses how professional ethics are in spot to guide professionals throughout their moral decision making. Within these honest suggestions is a subgroup of ethics called compulsory ethics. Lambie continues on to discuss the way the reporting of suspected child misuse falls under these necessary ethics which crosses barriers into all disciplines. In 1974, the Country wide Child Abuse Reduction and Treatment Action (PL 93-247) was enacted by Congress which identified child mistreatment as (42 USCS 5101):

Physical or mental personal injury, sexual maltreatment or exploitation, negligent treatment, or maltreatment of a child under the age of eighteen or the age specified by the child protection regulation of their state involved, by someone who is in charge of the child's welfare under circumstances which signify that the child's health or welfare is harmed or threatened in doing so.

In addition to the act handed down by congress every one of the states in america have transferred statutes which make it illegal for someone who knows an instance of child mistreatment not to survey it (North Carolina General Statutes, 2003). Based upon these laws and regulations and statutes, it is not only ethically needed that helping professionals report suspected child maltreatment but failure to do so may also bring about legal ramifications as well.

The field of mindset has an important service for those that are having trouble coping with a mental disability or other mental aspect of their life. As was mentioned earlier those that visit a psychologist as a patient are, many times, in a psychologically susceptible state. That is why it is especially very important to those within the field of mindset to check out the ethical recommendations developed for their field as directly as possible. The ones that are steadfast in their moral behavior help to ensure that their patients have the best treatment possible and reduce the likelihood of inflicting any mental health damage upon the individual.

Ethical Dilemmas in Felony Justice

Just like in the self-discipline of psychology, additionally it is exceptionally important to follow ethical suggestions within the willpower of unlawful justice. Those whose vocation falls within the self-discipline of legal justice end up within an authoritative role between those around them. This truth puts the average person in a position of having electric power over others. If the average person is not mindful, this electricity may be easily exploited. Again, as with psychology, dire implications may be endured. In some cases, innocent individuals may be wrongfully accused and convicted as the true guilty get together is freed in which case justice is not served. Cops who stray from moral action risk termination as well as having their reputation tarnished of their community. These facts make it necessary for those in unlawful justice, exactly like those within the field of psychology, to follow stringent ethical suggestions as well (See Appendix A). In this particular section the manuscript will discuss a few of the moral dilemmas that are experienced within the field of criminal justice.

One action that a police officer must inevitably be a part of is the use of drive. The action of applying drive is not unethical in itself though ethics do come into question when the utilization of force gets to the point of becoming excessive. In any case, excessive power is any make used beyond what is necessary to subdue an assailant. One visible case by which excessive force for legal reasons enforcement was brought to the forefront is the truth of Rodney Ruler (Cannon, 1997). During this incident, a video was used of LA Police Department officials striking King regularly with batons after he was laying on the ground.

Unethical patterns, such as was exhibited in cases like this, isn't just damaging to the average person doing the action, but it is also damaging to the law enforcement community all together. The use of excessive make by an official of regulations may lead to termination and, probably, legal repercussions such as restitution, prison time, or both. Activities such as this could also lead to an overall mistrust of the law enforcement community by individuals within the public which in turn can lead to civil unrest. Referring back again to the Rodney Ruler case, a long time after the reality tensions are still high within the Los Angeles community as a result of the occurrence as well as the occurrences that followed (Schoch & Lin, 2007). This should be a major concern because of the fact that police, as well as the other experts within the legal justice community, are in location to serve and protect the public and must be trusted when the time comes to perform their work.

Another ethical patterns that must be employed within any criminal justice profession, as well as any other profession, is the reduction of prejudice. Prejudice may be provided in many different forms including prejudice by contest, gender, social position, or any other individual requirements. One area of unlawful justice where prejudice is specially harmful is during jury selection. If the sitting jury is introduced into the courtroom with a preconceived prejudice founded upon some feature of the case, it may, in fact impede after an individual's to a good trial.

In most cases, prejudices may cause an individual to draw conclusions in regards to a defendant's guilt or innocence prior to the evidence against the defendant is even provided. There are numerous resources of prejudice, some of which include press publicity, community participation, gossip, and rumours (Vidmar, 2002). It really is because of this that jury selection for any given case is, sometimes, a long a drawn out process. Jury selection is useful to remove any individuals which may house a few of these prejudices, such as family and friends of any individuals mixed up in process, or any individuals that have been affected in any way by the sort of crime in question. Vidmar (2002) performed several circumstance studies upon court docket instances and their participation of pre- and midtrial prejudices some of which the pursuing paragraphs will summarize.

One case that Vidmar (2002) discusses is the situation of Regents of the College or university of California vs. Genentech (1999). The situation involved patent infringement on the hgh Protropin. The jurors have been chosen and a day for the trial had been set. Before the trial, defense lawyers had learned that Genentech got pled guilty in a national case concerning off label advertising of Protropin and had to pay $50 million. Certainly the defense legal representatives were concerned that information, if brought to light to the present jurors, could affect the results of the trial. The judge refused to delay the trial but did instruct the jurors to avoid reading any news articles that engaged the company Genentech. During the trial, the jurors were in a ready room waiting around to be called into the trial and one of the jurors helped bring with them a copy of the Oakland Tribune to read during the put it off. Once the juror considered the business portion of the paper one of the news stated what acquired happened in the previously mentioned circumstance Genentech was involved with. According to information, there is data recommending that several jurors also witnessed the same headline. Clearly, in a case such as this, the jury pool have been tainted to a certain degree with prejudice.

Another research study talked about by Vidmar (2002) included the case of R. v. Reynolds (1998). The truth handled a mother known as Louise Reynolds that were recharged with stabbing her 7-year-old little girl 84 times. During this period, significant amounts of community hostility have been aimed towards her after having a memorial poem of her composure have been published within the neighborhood newspaper. The protection had presented an alternative solution means through which Ms. Reynolds' girl might have been killed which involved a pit bull near the criminal offense picture that was found protected in blood. Your body of the kid was then exhumed and evaluated by two forensic scientists whose findings firmly supported the alternative means offered by the protection. These results were not published within the neighborhood papers but were protected in nationally circulated newspapers. In prep for a movement for a change of place, Vidmar conducted a survey assessing the level of hostility that still existed towards Ms. Reynolds. Out of the respondents, 75% said that these were capable of offering an impartial decision on the case. Of the same group that was surveyed, only 45% mentioned that a non-guilty verdict would be a satisfactory verdict in this case. Thus giving the sign that even though facts had been offered to get Ms. Reynolds' innocence, the hostility that was presented therefore of the printed poem still lingered to a qualification within those surveyed prejudicing their decisions.

As is evidenced above, honest behavior is detrimental to the correct exchange of justice. Unethical patterns within the criminal justice community may cause civil unrest, fake convictions, or worse. The daily interactions of these within one of the numerous criminal justice professions provide ample opportunities for maltreatment of electric power and dishonesty as well as much other unethical manners. Therefore it is vitally important for those within the unlawful justice community to be vigilant in their endeavors as well as strive to complete their responsibilities in an honest manner.


As one can see both disciplines of psychology and unlawful justice require strict ethical guidelines if they are to be professionally and effectively integrated. Specialists within both disciplines interact on a daily basis with people that are in just a vulnerable state. The consequences of unethical patterns within the confines of the disciplines can be greatly harmful to both professional as well as the individual that the professional is getting together with. Pros within the field of psychology risk dropping their practice as well as legal repercussions while the patients that are victim to the unethical action risk further damage to their already vulnerable mental state. Professionals within the criminal justice community risk termination, a tarnished reputation, and possibly even legal repercussions as well. The effects of unethical tendencies within legal justice deprive the damaged individuals of their right to justice while, in some of a lot more extreme cases, could even lead to civil unrest and a profound mistrust for the justice community all together. Given these facts, it is obvious the top role that ethics takes on in ensuring the success as well as the professionalism in both the disciplines of mindset and legal justice.

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)