The market allocates resources


The market allocates resources efficiently by the purchase price system. The "invisible side" of Adam Smith is something of prices, that will promote the makers and consumers making their own decision. Consumers make purchase decisions based on "utility maximization" while manufacturers make marketing decisions based on the process of "income maximization". Predicated on the changes in prices, the market segments guide resources toward the most efficient aspects of allocation between supply and demand.

Chandler (1977) offered that the enterprise's internal supervision and coordination as the "visible palm" was replacing the "visible hand" of market mechanisms. Along with the climb of modern company and its professionals, the large modern enterprise was gradually changed the tiny traditional family organization and was taking over the coordination function of market activities and tool allocations, as well as its management team were becoming the most influential group of economic decision manufacturers.

Actually, the "visible palm" is not really a denial of the "visible hand". The effect of both "invisible palm" and "visible palm" is conditional. Therefore, the "visible side" had not been completely upgrading the "visible palm"; it was a kind of supplement and development of the "invisible hand" from the point of view of administrative coordination.

How effective the marketplace allocates resources

For market, the purchase price system is the coordinating device that takes care of allocation. Price, which makes balance between the consumers' needs and the makers' supply, is achieved through relationship in the market. The procedure of market connections is exactly what we call the "invisible hand".

Demand and offer affect the marketplace interaction. On one hand, consumer's demand for a product depends upon its price to a huge extent. The total demand will rise if the purchase price goes down. This is actually the rule of demand. On the other hand, the total way to obtain goods is also determined by its price. The total supply will rise if the purchase price goes up. This is the law of source.

Figure 1 illustrates that whenever a product oversupply and the purchase price will drop, on the contrary, it will stimulate use, so that increase the demand. Besides, it will inhibit the creation, hence decrease the source. Market equilibrium occurs when the source curve and demand curve meet. The assembly point of source and demand needs to be performed through price alterations. At this time, resources will be allocated in a number of purposes through price. The market will out of equilibrium no matter supply excess demand or demand overrun resource. The price will be altered until equilibrium comes home.

However, the "invisible palm" is not a panacea. In real life, the market has its limitation in allocating resources. The "invisible hand" of market can be effectively only in the properly competitive market. People goods, externality, monopoly, market control lag, as well as the unbalanced information can lead to the disorder and chaos of the market economy. For example, according to statistics from "Sina Finance", there have been 80 big shops in 2005 in Beijing. A Beijing person's average purchasing ability was one- third of a person's buying power in Tokyo, while the volume of large shopping malls was 8 times greater than it in Tokyo. This Happening made an over-all decline in office stores' monetary benefits, thus malls finished down one after another. It shows that market has a certain degree of blindness and the marketplace mechanism will not always achieve their ideal express.

The management was affecting the current economic climate as a "Visible Hand"

Chandler posed the "Visible hands" of management, that was playing an ever-increasing key role in the allocation of resources. Today, the companies are not the small workshops any more in enough time of Adam Smith. Modern business enterprises were changing small traditional corporations. A few of them can be as rich as a country, which have great power to directly have an effect on national overall economy and even politics; moreover, they may make sense to the romantic relationships between countries as well. The company's management was participating in a significant impact on the allocation of resources.

Chandler indicates that prior to the rise of the modern enterprise, the tiny personally held and managed company was a single-unite firm, which charges an individual economic function and working a single products in a single location. Thus the activities of the small traditional companies were coordinated and controlled by market and price system. On the other hand, most of the modern business enterprise is multi-unit venture, which has its own administrative office, handles numerous kinds of products and services and performs diverse types of monetary activities in several areas. Therefore the activity of the unites and deals between them were internalized. These were coordinated and controlled by salaried managers rather than market mechanisms.

As some propositions which Chandler talked about in "The Apparent Palm" (1977), can offer that the "visible side" of management coordination was swapping the "invisible palm" of market mechanisms.

Fist of most, small traditional business will changed by modern multiunit business when administrative coordination allowed lower costs, higher production, and higher profits than coordination by market mechanisms. Modern corporations interiorized the ventures, which transacted between some business units before. This internalization may reduce exchange costs and information costs, improve production, provide a more stable cashflow and thus reduce costs to improved earnings.

Secondly, only by developing a formal managerial hierarchy can the benefits of the internal activities of several business units be created. In modern business enterprises, middle professionals control and coordinate the development and circulation in the business. Meanwhile, top professionals aren't only assess and coordinate with the intermediate professionals, but also replaced the marketplace for future creation and circulation of learning resource allocation.

Thirdly, the management system promotes the company's specialization and lasting development. A lot of the traditional corporations are partnerships and family businesses, which were always short-lived. In contrast, management hierarchy allows the functions of company be managed even the personnel turnover and makes the salaried managers becoming more professional through various formal trainings. The managerial power and ownership of enterprise can be divided when the business enterprise scale and the opportunity of operational diversity of business developed to a certain level, in the mean time the manager are more and much more professional

From the viewpoint of Chandler, to manage and coordinate this 'visible hands', compared to the 'unseen hands', could not only bring huge production and gains, but also enhance the competitiveness of capital. Thus, it could essentially promote the productivity and consumption which triggered by the revolution of organization management. That is what called 'the revolution of company management'

It can't be denied that the "visible hand" has turned into a increasingly more crucial role in the modern day economy, but there are still some defects in the view of Chandler's "visible hands". To begin with, Chandler's over-praise of the executive of corporation is just partly making sense somewhat. Managers may conceal various degrees of opportunism and potential trickery, such as the Enron scandal, as well as high-paying CEO scandal. Secondly, Chandler's understanding of large enterprise is not completely accurate. Businesses are growing for large companies, because there is some kind of asset specificity. Companies expanding the scale do not imply that it is competent enough to develop its durability. Take the American slaughter Gustavus in 19th century for example, he operate a train transfer business and fridge factory since it was the best way that he could control the quality and efficiency of meat-packing. He concerned about that he'd be plot in secret by his competition if buying transport services and freezers from others.

It is obviously that internal management of large venture would not swap the regulatory action of market, the "visible hands" would are likely involved only regarding management mechanism can produce increased productivity than the market mechanism and internal coordination costs are cheaper than the marketplace transfer costs.

To sum up, the marketplace allocates resources proficiently by making equilibrium between demand and offer through the price system, while the "visible side" coordinates and allocates resources by management. Every sword has its two attributes. Both "invisible hands" and the "visible hands" have their durability and weakness. The "visible hands" can not totally replace the "visible hand", as the "visible palm" is the dietary supplement and development of the "invisible side" from the facet of management coordination. They health supplement each other to ensure the allocation of tool processed efficiently.


  • Alfred D. , Jr. Chandler (1977) The Visible Hands The Managerial Revolution in American Business Massachusetts and London: Belknap Press of Harvard University or college Press. P. 1-4, P6-9
  • Eitan Goldman & Gary Gorton (2000 ) The Visible Side, The Invisible Side And Efficiency. National Bureau of Economic Research. JEL NO. D21, G30
  • Economypedia [online]. [Utilized 1th December 2009]. Available from World Wide Web : < http://www. economypedia. com/wiki/index. php?title=Production_function >
  • Economypedia [online]. [Seen 1th December 2009]. Available from World Wide Web : < http://www. economypedia. com/wiki/index. php?title=Market_interaction >
  • Jintang Wang & Wenfan Zhong (1995) Modern American large business and American world. Wuhan: Wuhan School Press. P3-5
  • Wikipedia [online]. [Accessed 1th December 2009]. Available from INTERNET : < http://en. wikipedia. org/wiki/The_Visible_Hand >
  • Wikipedia [online]. [Seen 1th December 2009]. Available from INTERNET :
  • Sean, Douma & Hein, Schreuder (2008) Economic Approaches to Organizations Essex: Pearson Education. P. 3-5, P9-10, P12-19, P28-38, P42-44, P46-51, P56-60
  • Sina [online]. [Reached 1th December 2009]. Available from INTERNET : < http://finance. sina. com. cn/b/20040607/1147799840. shtml>

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)