As Good As It Gets | Analysis

In the 1997 film As Good As It Gets, Jack port Nicholson offers an Academy Award-winning performance as Melvin Udall. Udall is a misanthropic relationship writer who works at home as a best-selling novelist in NEW YORK. He is suffering from obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) which, paired along with his misanthropy, puts off the neighbors in his Manhattan apartment building and almost everybody else with whom he comes into contact.

Melvin is middle-aged, probably in his overdue forties. He is a white men who's unmarried & most likely does not have a very effective love life beyond the fictitious tales of love that he weaves when he creates his best-selling novels. His profession to be a best-selling novelist has made him alternatively prosperous, allowing him to cover a good apartment in New York's Greenwich Town. But that doesn't mean that he's out partying with the elite of NY. Alternatively, he prefers the confines of his apartment. Although he has an acid tongue and is also unabashedly blunt along with his opinions, he's very introverted and prefers solace in his apartment, spending hours on his writing.

Melvin Udall does a lot of things that seem odd. He writes poetically in regards to a love he's never known. He's a bully who delights in heaping mistreatment on everyone unlucky enough to encounter him yet is impressed when someone has the guts to push back. He avoids touching other people but deliberately obstructs his favorite waitress so that she has to touch him to move. He speaks rudely and crudely to people but whispers great nothings to your dog: "You shouldn't be like me, not be like me. You stay just the way you are because you are a perfect man. " He's afraid of many things but typically frightened of others viewing his dread. He rejects first so that he won't have to put up with rejection. He lives the life span of the recluse. He is misogynistic. He's homophobic, as exhibited by his disdain and intolerance for Simon Bishop's homosexuality. He is anti-Semetic. He's racist, as exhibited by his inconsiderate habit toward Frank Sachs. He seems as if he must eat lunchtime at the same stand every day, and he always brings his own plastic utensils. He is brutally insensitive to others. He has a ritual to locking his door, turning to the top lock 3 x and the middle lock 5 times. He converts the lighting in his house on and off 5 times to carefully turn them on or off. He washes his hands with several brand new bars of cleaning soap and then discards them after having used them for just a few seconds. He strolls around splits. He eats breakfast time at the same desk in the same restaurant every day using throw-away plastic utensils he brings with him due to his pathological germophobia. Melvin is even powered so far as to unknowingly to a good deed for the only real waitress he allows to wait on him, Carol Connelly. Melvin hires his editor's spouse, an experienced pediatrician, to provide personal sessions and checkups to her ill boy, Spencer, at a lot of money. Melvin does indeed this for no reason apart from he would like Carol, who still left work to manage her ailing kid, another to work and wait around on him so that he can continue steadily to follow his compulsive regime. This displays how people who have OCD practically cannot stray from the road of their routine and will go to great measures to avoid doing so.

Other symptoms generally exhibited by people who have OCD include looking at rituals, such as going back often to check a door lock, even though each time the person locates it locked. Some individuals with OCD have violent thoughts. They may dread that they or someone they love will expire in an awful accident or that they can harm someone. One of these is individuals who fear that they have run down someone, so they return to the spot to check or quit driving.

As is stated in the DSM-IV-TR, people who have OCD suffer from repeated obsessions and/or compulsions.

Obsessions are consistent and repeated ideas, thoughts, and impulses or images that are experienced as intrusive and/or incorrect. They also incite marked panic or stress. These activities are difficult to dismiss, despite their disturbing nature. They are more intrusive that worries about real-life problems, and, what's worse, they're usually not related to real-life problems.

Melvin Udall has repeated thoughts about germs and diseases and will try to neutralize his intrusive thoughts with compulsive actions. Additionally it is made superior throughout AS EFFECTIVE AS It Gets that Melvin fills with anxiousness when his schedule is violated. His stress and anxiety skyrockets when he walks down the street, fearing he could step on a split.

Obsessive thoughts can press aside more considerations that the person needs to do and make the person feel compelled to do this. For instance, people may follow the same route to university even if it requires them kilometers out of their way or makes them later for course. Or they may let their uncertainties about coming in contact with the tree cause them to venture out and touch it again, only to doubt again whether they needed the action. Such people may follow their compulsions because they desire to ease the anxiety * they feel about their obsessions.

Melvin delivers his editor's man, a pediatrician, to make personal appointments to Carol's kid, Spencer, at top dollar, just so Carol will come in to work and hold out on Melvin's stand. Clearly this step appears extremely magnanimous, however in context, he is very centered on himself and his needs. Clearly it is ridiculous to pay a fortune for a continuing pediatrician for someone's boy, just to allow them to get back to their job and last, but Melvin's daily routine guidelines him because of his obsessive compulsive disorder.

Compulsions are recurring behaviors that those with OCD perform to try to suppress the nervousness associated with the obsessions. For example, people might have repeated, unnecessary doubts about if they have performed an important process, such as locking the entranceway. Or they could think that if indeed they do not walk the same path to institution every day, something terrible may happen to them or even to someone they love. Compulsions can also include increased or unreasonable cleaning, looking at a stove, side washing, asking for assurances, or mental functions, such as repeating certain words silently, keeping track of, or praying excessively. These behaviors either provide as coping mechanisms to reduce the distress with the panic or distress caused by the obsessive thoughts temporarily, or - unrelated to an obsession - these are performed relating to rules that must definitely be applied rigidly. In nearly all cases these activities are made to prevent some dreaded event or situation. Such people may follow their compulsions because they hope to ease the anxiety * they experience their obsessions. However, in other circumstances there is no obvious logical interconnection between the two.

Melvin Udall avoids stepping on breaks in the sidewalk because which may bring misfortune. A causal connection also is available when he engages in avoidance and ritualistic conducts because of his obsessive thoughts about contamination. The type avoids touching visitors to avoid bacteria. He brings his own utensils to his diner, so he doesn't have to risk contamination from unclean silverware. He lays out his plastic-ware in a ritualistic fashion, because this can help him feel less troubled since the world is currently more orderly and proper.

After having experienced OCD for a period, some subjects acknowledge that they are a product of their own head. They can also notice that their obsessions and/or compulsions are excessive or unreasonable. They experience their thoughts and activities as disagreeable with their own sense of self. These thoughts and habits take up a significant timeframe (several hour per day) and cause appreciable distress. Because they displace useful and satisfying patterns, these thoughts and habits can be highly disruptive to someone's normal regime, occupational or educational functioning, or regular public activities or romance with others.

Melvin appreciates that his obsessional thoughts are something of his own head because he displays on them in a discussion with Carol. Melvin understands that his compulsions are unreasonable. He instructs Carol that he sees a psychiatrist and started to take medicine in order to cope with his problem. Despite the fact that obsessive intrusions can be distracting, and frequently cause inefficient performance of cognitive tasks that require awareness, Melvin Udall is portrayed as a successful publisher. Sometimes he complains that his friends and neighbors distract him from his work, while his character's functioning as an publisher seems to remain largely intact. But whenever anything disrupts his well-established program, he becomes stressed and belligerent with people. Melvin gradually overcomes his isolation of have an impact on. He learns to recognize his emotions as well as the impact of his patterns on others.

Although it is made explicitly clear that Melvin suffers from OCD and, in the context of As Good As It Gets, OCD exclusively, Melvin exhibits some symptoms of other disorders, specifically cultural phobia, paranoid personality, and small antisocial disorder. Melvin demonstrates symptoms of social phobia. He prefers to stay in his room and work, isolated from his apartment neighborhood friends. Melvin's desire to take action is amplified when he berates his neighbor Simon Bishop and tells him that he shouldn't come and knock on his door, "not even if [Simon] hears the audio of the thud from [Melvin's] home and seven days later which smell via there that can only be a decaying human body and [Simon] must keep a hanky to [his] face because the stench is so think that [he] thinks [he's] going to faint. " Obviously he has an over-all disdain for his fellow man, which might lead one to believe that he has antisocial personality disorder, but Melvin informs Carol in the last mentioned 50 % of the movie that he is simply fearful of social connections because he himself knows the things he could tell people. He recognizes that his personality is not compatible with many peoples', so he involves the conclusion that, "none should be at the mercy of me. " Also considered for Melvin was an avoidant personality disorder, but Melvin doesn't by any means demonstrate the warning sign of being extremely sensitive to negative evaluation. For just as much as he dishes out in the movie, he gets close if not all of it back again. He requires it remarkably well. One indication of antisocial personality disorder that he shows is his absence at remorse for the devastating things he says to some people. For instance, the lady who approaches him at the elevator is bubbling with enthusiasm to ask him, "how he writes women so well" when he writes his romance novels. Melvin, frustrated, slashes her down by responding, "I believe of a man, then I take away reason and accountability, " with no remorse. In relation to antisocial personality disorder, Melvin also shows deceitfulness, impulsivity, irritability, and aggressiveness. Finally, Melvin shows little symptoms in the movie of having a paranoid personality, but his mistrust for others and his being vigilant of his environment aren't generalized, and so he couldn't be diagnosed with that disorder.

With relation to Axis I in the DSM, Melvin certainly suffers under a certain degree of nervousness, which skyrockets when he handles anybody of his many obsessions. This anxiety makes it moderately difficult for Melvin to function up to the specifications of society. As a result, Melvin has few friends and other intrapersonal issues involving his interactions with others.

Considering Melvin's OCD can be an Axis II personality disorder, he should show higher levels of dysfunction here. He has moderately difficult problems with functioning anticipated to his personality disorder. He's so indebted to his tedious, like his going to the same restaurant each day, seated in the same seats, buying the same food, and getting the same waitress, that he is merely tolerable, scarcely tolerable, when he comes after his regimen. The stress and anxiety would overwhelm him if some confounding factor induced him to stray from the road. In the As Good As It Gets, Melvin works very impulsively when his schedule is interrupted. When Carol doesn't come directly into work to hold back on him, he operates to her house and demands that she come directly into work. That is a humorous field in the movie, but it is also proof how people with OCD can bring themselves to violate communal norms and objectives, sometimes without spotting that they are carrying it out. When Melvin discovers that Carol has gone home to care for her sick boy, Spencer, he quickly formulates a plan to get Carol back into work. He hires the pediatrician to make personal visits to Spencer at Carol's home, so that Carol does not have to be concerned and will come back to work. That is at great financial cost to Melvin, who is lucky to really have the wealth, from his successful love novels, to be able to afford that. This is obviously not a good decision however, and was another quick decision made on impulse by a guy whose obsessions were consistently getting the best of him. His impulsivity can be an impairment in functioning that triggers him to possess his intrapersonal connection issues. This brings about him having no friends.

I'm ready to give Melvin a "little or nothing notable" ranking on both Axis III and Axis IV. I only do that because nothing of Melvin Udall's medical history or present medical problems is reviewed, other than the actual fact that he is encouraged to have pills for his OCD by his psychotherapist. With regards to Axis IV, he does not have any psychosocial problems other than a general and a public anxiety scheduled to his obsessions. Environmentally, Melvin is not terribly infected, besides that simple fact that he lives next to Simon Bishop who, by proximity, is the main topic of a lot of Melvin's scorn.

I would give Melvin an overall Axis V ranking of 60-65. I wouldn't go so far as to state that Melvin's symptoms are "serious. " Though he demonstrates highly-developed obsessions, compulsions, and other symptoms of OCD, they impact his overall degree of functioning only over a moderate level in my opinion. He certainly has few friends, with only Simon, and his waitress Carol having any evidence of camaraderie with Melvin. He comes with an immense difficulty relating to people or managing his blunt personality, which presents with many social conflicts. However, even when he strays from his regimen by going on the trip with Simon and Carol to see Simon's parents, he is still doesn't present any true breakdown in performing.

Doctors are not sure what can cause OCD. However, they suspect that the reason consists of neurotransmitters in the mind that aren't sending signals accurately. Udall talks about how, hesitant at first, he finally begins taking the pills to help with his OCD. This demonstrates that biologically, OCD can be contributed to medicine that impacts an integral part of the body, the mind.

Even though the portrayal of OCD seems practical in most parts of this As Good As It Gets, it would be improbable for clients to handle a dog when they have an obsession about cleanliness as severe as this identity. It's also amazingly hard to assume that Melvin is completely comfortable going out of his home city and actually his routine. It is implied and realized that Melvin eats at Caf 24, Carol's restaurant, every day as a compulsion, and abruptly Melvin is segregated from that program, yet he seems perfectly fine about any of it.

Melvin Udall's former or childhood is not discussed by any means in AS EFFECTIVE AS It Gets. The movie targets Melvin's present. I'd believe however, that Melvin developed his obsessions as a much youthful man, and did the trick over time to build up compulsions for them. However, because the compulsions are a form of negative support for the anxiety, he would become more and more dependent on the compulsions over time, meaning that most likely he's probably very indebted to them currently in the movie.

In the movie As Good as it Gets, Melvin's psychotherapist suggests that he take pills for his OCD, pills that will probably effect his serotonin levels. However, this is not the only means to which OCD can be suppressed.

Exposure and response prevention is behavioral approach has been found successful in dealing with compulsions. For example, clients like Melvin Udall try to avoid germs in excessive ways. They face a surface that they imagine is contaminated, such as a doorknob, and asked never to rinse their hands (response elimination). Visibility techniques include organized desensitization, paradoxical treatment, flooding, and satiation either in vivo or in creativeness.

The cognitive-behavioral therapy approach aspires for cognitive restructuring by discovering and challenging the cognitive distortions. Patients like Melvin could be subjected to exercises that help them postpone compulsion over an obsession or to pay attention to their obsessive thoughts and realizing how it makes them feel so that they can drown out the anxiousness. Another creative strategy is to have clients record their obsessive applying for grants an audio tape and play it back again to themselves until their distress decreases.

Sometimes leisure or body-focused methods are employed. Clients who have problems with OCD are generally very intelligent, much like Melvin, and have a tendency to spend lots of time ruminating in their heads, at the expense of being focused and laid back in their body. They can be sensitized to their thoughts and impulses, but are often out of touch with the body. Therefore, body-focused solutions are advised.

Clients like Melvin who suffer from OCD have poor cultural skills because they're twisted up in their obsessions and compulsions, and therefore are oblivious to normal courtesies, to communal context, and to other's perception of these. This point is verified over and over again in the movie as Melvin humorously stumbles through his intrapersonal relationship. Using interpersonal psychotherapy, the therapist first features the ways that the clients' current working, social interactions and goals within these human relationships may have been causal in their problems and eventually helps them explore problem romantic relationships and consider possibilities to solve them.

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)