Evaluate Three Approaches To Treating A Mental Disorder Psychology Essay

Despite the development and increased participation of medications within the treatment of mental disorder, Psychological solutions remain vital as a way to aid in the effective and long-term treatment of such conditions. It really is with these treatments, that patients can experience substantive if not full recoveries to permit for 3rd party and healthy function within world.

When looking at effective treatments of mental disorder, there are three main methods that outline the course of such treatments. These are the behavioural, psychodynamic and cognitive models.

One such remedy used within the treating mental disorder is rationale emotive therapy. Rationale emotive remedy or R. E. T, works over the cognitive style of abnormality's principle, a person's maladaptive and harmful behaviours are a result of faulty cognitions. R. E. T, created by Ellis (1962) is based on the Ellis ABC model which talks about how activating occurrences lead to a person's developed belief and therefore create a consequence or behaviour. The idea of the remedy is by challenging a person's irrational and faulty thoughts (cognitions), they could be replaced with an increase of rational and positive beliefs. The aim is that in challenging and changing these faulty thought processes, it will modify someone's resulting behaviour.

R. E. T is mainly used within the treatments of panic based illness such as depressive disorder and eating disorders, and has shown to be an extremely effective treatment. Knaus and Noker (1975) assessed R. E. T as cure for both nervousness and self-belief by completing a study relating students at an American school. Their research subjected 54 students to 85 consultations of R. E. T (comprising 10 to thirty minutes each) over 23 weeks. To assist in the understanding of the effectiveness of R. E. T, another group undertaking placebo trainings (consisting of semi-organised dialogue) was also completed. Results found that one month following the treatment got ceased, the group cared for with R. E. T experienced significantly higher self-esteem ratings and low stress and anxiety scores when analyzed in comparison to that of the placebo group. This study proved that when compared to speak based remedy or no remedy whatsoever, R. E. T works well at bettering cognition based disorder.

Despite this research study however, this shows that R. E. T is only effective when dealing with anxiety centered disorder, so when used against other illness such as schizophrenia, studies like this of Engles (1993) have found it ineffective. His study revealed that R. E. T was far better at treating the anxiety brought on by the maladaptive implications of the illness such as aesthetic and auditory hallucinations than the condition itself. Because of this, R. E. T cannot be seen as a versatile treatment for everyone mental disorders. Another issue relating to this therapy is that of patient involvement. The therapy itself is based on the therapist challenging the thoughts and cognitions of the patient to cause them to come to the realisation that these are negative and unrealistic. However, patients who are specially vulnerable and lack assertive self-esteem may get angry or protective when put through the theory that their views and thoughts are incorrect. This might lead to a huge drop-out rate during treatment.

One of the most important things to consider when looking at and analyzing therapies is that of ethics. The Uk Psychological Contemporary society (B. P. S) and British Relationship of Counselling and Psychotherapy (B. A. C. P) created and launched a guideline of Ethics to be accompanied by all therapists to be able to protect the interest of both themselves and their patients when under treatment. These ethical suggestions include four main concepts that give attention to admiration, competence, responsibility and integrity.

One of the significant ethnical problems with R. E. T is within label of what's an irrational notion. When treating folks from different cultures, specifically those with strong religious beliefs, what may been an irrational thought to the therapist maybe a significantly religious one to the patient. When referring this to the moral guidelines it states "A psychologist should value individual, cultural and role variations of the client" (As sighted in B. P. S. code of ethical guidelines 1. 1- requirements of general respect). This means that due the fact R. E. T can have large moral effects on someone's fundamental religious trust by challenging them as irrational cognitions; this remedy is at risk of breaking this honest guideline.

This treatment overall can be hugely useful and also affordable compared to other therapies, as little else is necessary in the procedure process other than a trained therapist and the patient. However it is important to note, that in some cases, depending on the individual patient and the extent of the mental disorder, R. E. T maybe required over several years and for that reason costs can significantly increase.

Due to the aim of R. E. T being the substitute of faulty cognitions with more productive and logical ones, R. E. T can be extremely effective in the treatment of ambiance disorders and eating disorders such as unhappiness and anorexia. This is because in such disorders, there's a clear underlying faulty thinking process that brings about the behaviour, like a patient experiencing anorexia thinking "easily eat that I'll get fat and no one will like me". Because of this, the challenging and changing of the way of thinking can produce effective results. However, in a few more complex kinds of mental disorder such as schizophrenia, R. E. T is a lot less effective. It is because within schizophrenia, the illness often manifests itself by means of audio and visual hallucinations and for that reason there is absolutely no clear thinking process that contributes to such symptoms. This implies R. E. T is unable to find a faulty way of thinking to challenge and as a result, R. E. T is no appropriate therapy to use in such circumstances.

When taking a look at the behavioural way, one such therapy used is that of aversion therapy. Aversion therapy is dependant on the classical conditioning concept that behavior is learned through association. The idea of aversion remedy is to web page link the particular behaviour that will require changing to a poor cognition, response or involuntary action. In doing this, the patients mind learns to associate the behaviour with the negative response given and therefore the behaviour ceases. This form of therapy works well in the treating things such as alcohol and sex dependency. The remedy itself uses a number of different methods in order to make the link between behavior and negative response. One particular method, used in combination with alcohol craving is emetic drugs. The purpose of this to get the individual to consume alcohol made up of this emetic medication that's induces nausea, vomiting and cramping of the tummy. After periods of time the patients head will associate alcohol with the negative replies of the drug and so craving of this substance will stop. In situations of sex habit (used in American prisons for treatment of paedophilia), one is shown images of individuals. When one's appear that are unclothed or sexual in nature, an electric shock is directed at the patient when intimate arousal is shown. Again similar to the alcohol addiction, the individual will associate erotic thoughts with pain from the shocks and thus change the behaviour.

Aversion remedy can be most reliable when looking at the treatment of addictions and patterns that affect a person's ability to function productively, such as gambling, sex and liquor. Once such case study, demonstrating aversion therapy's effectiveness was that of an individual experiencing trichotillomania (excessive hair tugging). Patient A possessed attempted several types of remedy including a behavioural self-control program but without success. After 16 years of the disorder patient A was given aversion therapy, subjecting her to small electric shocks when wanting to pull her head of hair. The consequences were almost immediate and follow up checks continued to show improvement aside from times of extreme stress. This research study provides us with research that when in comparison to other treatments, aversion therapy can be extremely effective for a few individuals. However, while a strong indication as to the success of aversion therapy, circumstance studies only give us an understanding into individual situations and thus we cannot get an clear understanding of the effectiveness of such a remedy on a wider scale. As a result, case studies such as this one do not give us reliable, valid and medically testable data.

Despite case studies proving the potency of this therapy, there a wide range of therapists that argue the lasting ramifications of this treatment are poor, and soon after it is concluded, patients often deviate back to the maladaptive behaviours fist exhibited. Aswell as this, it's important to look at the appropriateness of such a treatment. The use of aversion remedy has seen significant changes in organizations of people being affected by craving or behavioural complications (behaviors) as behavioural modifiers such as electric shocks can be applied when the undesired behavior is shown. However aversion remedy will be ineffective against such mental disorders like schizophrenia, personality disorder or unhappiness where the undesired behaviour is shown regularly and to some degree is built in to the personality of the individual, to the main point where they don't realize its existence. As a result, applying shocks to someone who doesn't understand what they doing wrong would simply increase anxiety and stress to the patient rather than remedy them.

Another essential aspect when looking at aversion therapy is cost. Because of the behavioural modifiers used such as chemical type drugs and electric shocks, the price of such a therapy, in particular when confronting slight addictions can be extremely high.

When taking a look at the ethical implications of aversion remedy, the guidelines state "Psychologists should avoid harming clients, but remember that interests of different clients may conflict" (As sighted in B. P. S. code of moral recommendations 3. 1- specifications of basic responsibility). However by exposing patients to electric shocks and chemicals that creates abdominal cramps and vomiting, the increase in both anxiety and stress within patients, as well as the physical harm they are positioned in both challenges and risks breaking this honest guideline.

Another therapy that is used in the treating mental disorder is psychoanalysis. Produced by Freud (1910), psychoanalysis was made because of this of the psychodynamic style of abnormality. This model declares a person's abnormal behaviour is a direct result of repressed unconscious conflict or trauma. The idea of psychoanalysis is to help make the unconscious repressed thoughts conscious and thus be able to identify the reason and main to the behaviour and understand it. The remedy itself involves a trained therapist building a therapeutically strong marriage with the individual to build up trust. The therapist then allows the patient to express themselves and their thoughts (known as transference) while left over neutral and impartial (showing no thoughts or judgement). The ultimate aim for the remedy is to then permit the therapist to interpret the significance of these unconscious incidents and emotions, allowing the individual to have substantially better self-knowledge and insight, permitting them to adjust their behaviours.

Psychoanalysis was one of the first 'talking solutions' created and since its labor and birth this concept has been used and progressed into many therapies like the desires of C. B. T (cognitive behavioural therapy). As a result, studies like this of Bergin have the ability to support the effectiveness of psychoanalysis. Bergin (1971) analysed 10, 000 patient histories of those who entered treatment and classified them into several organizations including cured, improved, slightly improved rather than improved upon/left treatment. His results discovered that 80% increased under psychoanalysis in comparison to 65% under other treatments. This analysis clearly supports the effectiveness of psychoanalysis as cure by identifying its results compared to that of other solutions.

However, studies such as Bergin's (1971) hold biased due to what is classed as advanced and what's classed as just a bit increased are completely open to interpretation. This means there is no accurate scientific measurement open to identify what is categorized as upgraded, slightly improved and not improved. Because of this, each therapist will keep their own specific ideas of what is classed as advanced and so these results are not reliable.

As well as this, other studies, including that of Smith et al (1980) who looked at over 475 studies of therapy, found psychoanalysis in comparison with other remedies as a cure for depression was forget about effective than placebo treatments. This research by themselves disputes Bergin's claim that psychoanalysis is an efficient treatment. Despite these arguments against psychoanalysis, there are positive rationales for its use. One particular reason is that of face validity. Since there is little evidence to support Freud's theory that unconscious issues have effects on conscious behavior, the idea that having the ability to speak to someone to be able expressing your emotions and emotions can help you are feeling better in yourself makes sense, thus retaining face validity. In addition, it promotes the idea that it is okay to talk about your problems and 'start up' to people to be able to increase your own self-understanding.

One of the largest impacts on the utilization of psychoanalysis however is its ethics. As humans, our imagination can sometimes lock away prior and historical stress in order to allow for normal function. Which means that a person may see or be engaged in injury so horrific, that the mind locks it away inside our unconscious to avoid it regressing and safeguarding the mind of the person. As a result, with out a clear patient history available, psychoanalysis may start this past unconscious trauma, having it to the mindful causing the individual to re-live it without the abilities or abilities to handle such a predicament and placing them under emotional and psychological injury. When looking at the ethical guidelines put in place it claims "therapists should be alleviating personal distress and hurting" (as sighted in B. A. C. P Worth of counselling and psychotherapy). As a result, by providing such trauma to the top, a therapist will be breaking these moral guidelines.

All in all, psychoanalysis has hardly any strong supporting research to show its efficiency as a remedy, however as reviewed, it does maintain face validity as a thought. As well as this, the therapy itself, compared to that of others is predominately in-expensive, however one might claim that treatment under psychoanalysis may take years depending on issues arising and specific, so cost could increase over longer duration. One of the biggest positives of this treatment however, is the fact that it can be used for almost any mental illness and therefore is very diverse. Whether its schizophrenia, depression or an eating disorder, having the ability to sit with a tuned therapist and talk about your recent and present feelings and issues makes this remedy both appropriate and healing to nearly every condition.

Despite the advantages and weaknesses to these treatments, without internal input and therapy, many patients would neglect to make recoveries. When coupled with the ever developing world of drug based medications, treatments such as these continue to show successful in the treating mental disorders.

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)