The Concepts Of Alienation And Anomie Sociology Essay

This essay will compare the ideas of 'alienation' and 'anomie'. Karl Marx first specified his theory of alienation within the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts (1844) and refers to a define set of social relationships which were first produced in feudal societies which in turn became disrupted by modern professional society. Marx himself said when speaking about this issue of alienation "The staff member becomes poorer a lot more riches he produces and the greater his production boosts in electricity and degree. The staff member becomes an ever before cheaper commodity the greater goods he creates. The devaluation of the individual world increases in direct regards to the upsurge in value of the world of things. Labour will not only create goods; it also produces itself and the staff member as a item, and even in the same percentage as it produces goods". Anomie however, is defined by Emile Durkheim as an alteration in "normalness" and a breakdown of social restrictions. Durkheim became enthusiastic about the public condition characterised with a breakdown of 'norms' governing cultural interactions. "The condition of anomie is impossible wherever organs solidly associated with each other are in sufficient contact, and in sufficiently lengthy contact. Indeed, being next to each other, they are often alerted in every situation to the need for just one another and therefore they experience an enthusiastic, continuous sense of their common dependence. " (Durkheim, E: 1893). Durkheim went on to develop his interest of anomie further when he began his research into 'Suicide', where he suggested that when a person's 'norms' and rules that regulate their lifestyle become week, this can lead to a kind of suicide which he called 'Anomic Suicide'.

Marx assumed that there have been four degrees of alienation that break down the fundamental website link that humans have with their self defining qualities. Firstly there exists 'product alienation' which Marx assumed was alienating to the staff member because the merchandise that they produce do not represent their creative energies and are simply just objects made by the command line of the company (Ransome, P: 2010). Which he argues was within industrialised society however, not in feudal societies therefore of capitalism and its economical gain fuelled world. (Morrison, K: 2006). Subsequently, Marx said that alienation could result from 'function of creation'. This, matching to Marx is linked to 'product alienation' as the merchandise of labour is alienating then so is the function of production. So in capitalist societies people have no choice but to work and feel alienated to meet their basic needs. Marx's work explained that "The staff member feels himself only when he is no longer working; when he's working he will not feel himself his labour is therefore not voluntary but required" (Marx, K: 1844). Thirdly, Marx advised that there is alienation scheduled to 'common goal'. He outlined that this occurred whenever a worker's social connections become debased and they are extracted from a cooperative communal dimension, for example on manufacturing plant lines and in available offices. Finally the fourth alienation type that Marx composed about was 'alienation from mankind'. Marx presumed that this took place whenever a person proved helpful long hour times -as Marx published in the Victorian society this is extremely common- and alongside the three other varieties of alienation; a person lost their sense of mankind and became alienated of their own inner home (Ransome, P: 2010).

Durkheim however argued that anomie in the division of labour equally that of alienation, deprived individuals of a sense of connection with world (Ransome, P: 2010). Durkheim presumed that this sense of deprivation caused visitors to become disorientated and anxious and observed anomie among the social factors that inspired suicide (Giddens, A: 2009). He argued that there were four types of suicide: Altruistic, Anomic, Egoistic and Fatalistic (Pope, W: 1976). Altruistic suicide being too much public integration, for example suicide bombers give up their life for the needs of these cultural group (Giddens, A: 2009). Egoistic suicide, in Durkheim's terms was anticipated to insufficient rules. This is observed in societies such as religious groups; Durkheim discovered that suicide was higher in the Protestant religious beliefs than it was in Catholic religious groups. He believed that was due to the Catholic religion having a far more strict regulations, so therefore people assumed that it was 'against god' to commit suicide and also with the Catholic culture being greater regulated, he believed that closer connected modern culture made the people have a greater sense of community and moral beliefs so did not wish to commit suicide (Ransome, P: 2010). Durkheim related the low suicide rates during World Battle 1 to this as he assumed the face associated with an external enemy brought about social integration (Giddens, A: 2009). Fatalistic suicide for Durkheim was anticipated to excess rules. This can be seen in contemporary culture in prisons as people feel that they haven't any sense of future or do it yourself worthy of. However Durkheim noticed that this type of suicide was of little importance in modern society but it was of specific historical interest. Historically, this is noticeable in the slave areas in America through the civil conflict (Morrison, K: 2006). Durkheim argued that Anomic suicide occurs when guidelines and 'norms' that govern a person's lifestyle become unpredictable and breakdown. He looked at this subject matter of suicide by researching the suicide rates of professional society during intervals of economic problems created by financial tough economy and durations of monetary change. Between 1845 and 1869 in European countries, Durkheim determined that there is a rapid surge in suicide rates, which he from the economic state at that time as there is repeated economic problems, which led to a dramatic drop available cycle and severe bankruptcies. He also recognized that there was a specific structure of the suicide rates during this time across European countries; he discovered that there was a rise in the rates of suicide as the state of the current economic climate decreased, and when the turmoil deteriorated the rates dropped. However as the economy worsened again, the suicides increased (Morrison, K: 2006).

When taking into account Durkheim's theory of 'Anomic Suicide' and Marx's four types of alienation, maybe it's argued that we now have several similarities between your two social ideas. 'Alienation' in basic terms defines the relationship that a staff member -mainly- has with the beneficial role and their home being within modern culture. 'Anomie' can be suggested to relate to this similarly as it seems that it defines a person's do it yourself being within culture and themselves. However, critiques have advised that the theory of anomie for Durkheim was not in fact with regards to a person but it refers to society, although there are certain implications of a person's mind-set in his works (Robinson, J; Shaver P and Wrightsman, L: 1991). When discussing the main topic of anomie, social thoughts of other sociologists must be taken into account. Robert Mereton lengthened Durkheim's thoughts on anomie and emphasised that an individual intensifies their anomie when they thought we would discard their 'norms' to acquire to their elaborate desires and thus anomie and deviant behavior pull from a disjunction between a culturally approved aspiration of any society and socially designed strategies for creating those aspirations (Giddens, A: 2009). Durkheim's theory of anomie can be seen as very much like both Mereton's interpretation of anomie and Marx's theory of alienation in conditions of isolation and disorientation. However plainly it can be seen that there surely is a significant difference in retrospect to money being the source of the proletarian's lifestyle and the idea that it will keep the ruling course on top and all of those other inhabitants down in terms of Marx's considered alienation, where as Durkheim dealt with the themes of attitudes and anticipations of the society within his theory of anomie and folks resisting and getting the choice of their lifestyle rather than having into lifestyles similarly in alienation (Perry, R: 2007).

Although Marx and Durkheim's explanations are evidently the classical concepts of these ideas, it's been suggested that modern day culture has obscured these definitions. It can be said that 'Alienation for Marx and Anomie for Durkheim were metaphors for a radical episode on the prominent institutions and values of industrial world'. Out of this they undertake similar issues, but in various perspectives; Marx got on the conception of the partnership between man and world and the 'value of independence from constraint' through the eye of electric power and change. Durkheim however, was thinking about the 'transcendental value and moral constraint' through problems with maintenance of order. When considering Marx and Durkheim's research however there are critiques that need to be looked at. Many people argued that Durkheim's research on anomie and suicide could not be one hundred percent accurate; this is since it was obvious that Durkheim used other people's research and didn't perform his own. Durkheim used suicide statistics in Germany, however these figures were used by Durkheim at face value rather than critiqued. And yes it could be argued that Durkheim's interdependence theory might not exactly have been completely free from his own record assumptions and laden judgement. The primary article that needs to be considered when studying suicide is "Just how do some deaths get categorised as suicides?" relating to Atkinson, J (1978). When considering this question it makes one consider if the initial research and also Durkheim's assumptions were one hundred percent because the study was conducted across Germany, with statistics from various coroners, who each would arguably experienced their own laden judgement in regards to what constitutes as suicide. So it is argued that Durkheim was taking what the coroner constituted as suicide then the suicide categories are not objective facts but interpretations and meanings given to a specific event. Therefore to did his research more accurately and to allow no criticisms Durkheim must have conducted his own research. He might have probably done this by speaking with people that contain themselves attempted to commit and groups of those people who have, to find the different reasons behind the attempted or real suicide (Atkinson, J: 1978).

One could initially dispute that Capitalism is the primary reason behind both alienation and anomie. In anomie, Durkheim noticed a number of indications relating to anomie in the overdue nineteenth century such as industrial discord and marital separation; which he thought was related to the industrial world and the development of capitalism (Durkheim, E: 1893). However, Marx presumed that alienation was aided by capitalism. He presumed this as there was a fiercely competitive aspect of capitalism that obligated business such as factories to step up their method of production and productivity, to gain financial status and ability (Marx, K: 1844).

In bottom line, Alienation in retrospect means people becoming isolated from contemporary society consequently from industry and Anomie in retrospect is an alteration in normalness of these social status. It is clear from this you can dispute that alienation and anomie could both suggest isolation to a person but however in various forms. Then it could be argued that alienation is isolation of an person of their economic position quo, and anomie is isolation of any human being from their social position quo and personal norms. However from the info throughout the article it may also be suggested that the distinctions between alienation an anomie comes from the status of the principles, as alienation is said to be relate and revolve to a person singularly, where as anomie is thought to describe a social group somewhat than one individual alone. To conclude, it can be argued that there alienation and anomie have both similar and unique ideas. This is evident from the resources used throughout the essay, however it cannot be regarded as completely as research or information that is gathered is never completely reliable.

Also We Can Offer!

Other services that we offer

If you don’t see the necessary subject, paper type, or topic in our list of available services and examples, don’t worry! We have a number of other academic disciplines to suit the needs of anyone who visits this website looking for help.

How to ...

We made your life easier with putting together a big number of articles and guidelines on how to plan and write different types of assignments (Essay, Research Paper, Dissertation etc)